More Pages: Southwest Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80


A complete waste of money
don't buy this book - title misleading, poor information
The title misrepresents the contents as no Baja information

Better no guidebook at all than this area "guide"!Actual route descriptions are VERY OUT OF DATE! For example if you follow the advise and climb Mt. Ortokara, you will be probably killed by a rockfall, since nobody climbs that side of the Bezingi valley for many years, due to the Global Warming and glacier melting. Route schemes are very detailless and shabby! The routes numbering is a mess! Grades are simply stated in Russian system where a 250-meter rock climb in Crimea and The Russian route on Mt. Everest have the same 5 A grade! There is absolutely no useful practical information in this brochure. On the contrary the book is often misleading even in safety issues. For instance it doesn't even mention the dangers of crossing into or even getting close to the southern slopes of the Range (Shkhelda valley in summer) , lest being robbed or murdered by the Svans, whose land descended into a complete lawlessness in the recent years.
Feel free to reach me with any questions on DETAILS of REAL, CURRENT CONDITIONS of climbing in the North Caucasus at potap75@hotmail.com
Better no guidebook at all than this area "guide"!Actual route descriptions are VERY OUT OF DATE! For example if you follow the advise and climb Mt. Ortokara, you will be probably killed by a rockfall, since nobody climbs that side of the Bezingi valley for many years, due to the Global Warming and glacier melting. Route schemes are very detailless and shabby! The routes numbering is a mess! Grades are simply stated in Russian system where a 250-meter rock climb in Crimea and The Russian route on Mt. Everest have the same 5 A grade! There is absolutely no useful practical information in this brochure. On the contrary the book is often misleading even in safety issues. For instance it doesn't even mention the dangers of crossing into or even getting close to the southern slopes of the Range (Shkhelda valley in summer) , lest being robbed or murdered by the Svans, whose land descended into a complete lawlessness in the recent years...


Watt's Cliche

A Negative Approach To The ProblemThe second half of the book contains a very nice, brief description of the most well known rock art sites throughout the greater four corners area. The short descriptions are accompanied by well presented black and white photos representing type examples of petroglyphs in each area.
The book contains some useful information if one can glean it from the negative dialogue.


don't bother

Daniel does it again...

...

Vacuous and uninformativeSince this is an ethnography, you occasionally learn a fact or two, like the fact that there's more things written in English than in Navajo -- which the reader could possibly have predicted from the facts that Navajoland is surrounded by the US, and that most Navajos were not taught to read and write Navajo in school. But because this book is from the bad old days of 1980s postmodern anthro, the facts are few and far between, and the book's 200-odd pages are filled with navel-gazing about how challenging it is to write about this subject which the author would be writing about (i.e., Navajos and literacy) if he weren't instead writing ABOUT writing about it.
If this were exactly the only book ever written about Native Americans and/or literacy, it might be worth reading. Lucking, there are other books, which makes it hard for me to imagine there ever being a reason to spend time reading this empty and uninformative book. Instead, consider these, just to name a few:
Margaret Bender's /Signs of Cherokee Culture: Sequoyah's Syllabary in Eastern Cherokee Life/
Deborah House's /Language shift among the Navajos: Identity Politics and Cultural Continuity/
Ross Woodruff's /The Development of the Navajo Orthography and the Translation of the Navajo New Testament/
Bernard Spolsky's /Linguistics in Practice: the Navajo Reading Study/

